Shows like The Order
12 titles that share something real with The Order, each on a streaming service you may already pay for, with one honest line on why.
Out to avenge his mother's death, a college student pledges a secret order and lands in a war between werewolves and practitioners of dark magic.
The Order streams on · 2019
- Netflix
12 titles, where they stream, and why
The Originals2013
Supernatural factions clash over power and territory, driven by dark secrets and ancient loyalties.
- Prime Video
- Peacock Premium
Legacies2018
Young people at a school navigate witch, vampire, and werewolf politics in a darkly playful tone.
- Netflix
Mushoku Tensei: Jobless Reincarnation2021
A young man thrown into an unfamiliar world pursues a personal mission through danger and hidden power.
- Hulu
Riverdale2017
A seemingly normal small town hides dark, sinister secrets beneath its surface, unraveling around young adults.
- Netflix
The Vampire Diaries2009
College-age characters are drawn into a world of supernatural creatures, secret histories, and shifting allegiances.
- Max
- Peacock Premium
Grimm2011
An ordinary person discovers a hidden world of monsters and must balance a double life with real danger.
- Prime Video
- Peacock Premium
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina2018
A young protagonist straddles two worlds — one ordinary, one steeped in dark magic and secret societies.
- Netflix
Skins2007
Shares a college-age ensemble and raw, irreverent tone, though without supernatural elements.
- Hulu
Every Witch Way2014
A teenager abruptly discovers she is a witch and must navigate a world of competing magical factions.
- Paramount+
Pretty Little Liars2010
A group of young people uncovers dangerous secrets buried within a seemingly tight-knit community.
- Max
- Hulu
Titans2018
Young adults with extraordinary abilities operate in a dark, morally complex world of hidden factions.
- Max
My Hero Academia: Vigilantes2025
A timid college student is recruited into a secret, dangerous world and must grow into his new role.
- Netflix
US streaming availability as of November 5, 2026. Platforms change their catalogs; Kueup checks before every pick.
Get picks like this every week
Tell Kueup what you love. It sends three picks a week on the platforms you already have — free, no card.
Get my picks
