Shows like Supernatural
12 titles that share something real with Supernatural, each on a streaming service you may already pay for, with one honest line on why.
When they were boys, Sam and Dean Winchester lost their mother to a mysterious and demonic supernatural force. Subsequently, their father raised them to be soldiers. He taught them about the paranormal evil that lives in the dark corners and on the back roads of America ... and he taught them how to kill it. Now, the Winchester brothers crisscross the country in their '67 Chevy Impala, battling every kind of supernatural threat they encounter along the way.
Supernatural streams on · 2005
- Prime Video
- Peacock Premium
12 titles, where they stream, and why
Haikyu!!2014
Shares an underdog drive and intense sibling-like bonds forged through rivalry and teamwork.
- Netflix
- Hulu
Neon Genesis Evangelion1995
Teenagers carry the weight of humanity's survival against monstrous, otherworldly threats.
- Netflix
The Vampire Diaries2009
Two brothers with a fraught bond navigate a world overrun by dangerous supernatural creatures.
- Max
- Peacock Premium
Grimm2011
A man with a hidden lineage hunts monsters lurking beneath the surface of everyday American life.
- Prime Video
- Peacock Premium
The Haunting of Hill House2018
A family bound by trauma confronts terrifying supernatural forces rooted in their own past.
- Netflix
Every Witch Way2014
A teenager suddenly discovers a hidden supernatural identity and must learn to control new powers.
- Paramount+
American Horror Story2011
Anthology horror covering haunted houses, cults, and dark supernatural forces across American settings.
- Prime Video
- Disney+
- Hulu
- FuboTV
My Daemon2023
A boy and a companion travel a dangerous road, hunted by dark forces while trying to save family.
- Netflix
Angel1999
A cursed, brooding hero fights supernatural evil city by city, driven by guilt and a need for redemption.
- Hulu
The Sandman2022
A powerful figure journeys across strange realms to reclaim what was lost, facing dark mythological forces.
- Netflix
American Horror Stories2021
Stand-alone horror stories drawing on myths and legends, much like the monster-of-the-week format.
- Hulu
The Order2019
A young man driven by a family tragedy infiltrates a secret world of dark magic and werewolves.
- Netflix
US streaming availability as of November 5, 2026. Platforms change their catalogs; Kueup checks before every pick.
Get picks like this every week
Tell Kueup what you love. It sends three picks a week on the platforms you already have — free, no card.
Get my picks
